[OCAD]REVIEW

Results

172 official (+189 reruns) hide comments

1.	Olof Larén-Sandgren		Växjö OK	1:19		*****
	Speed settings are good, like the looks (even though the forest seems a bit odd), but the marshes are way too fast I think.Could be really awesome this thing.
2.	mr		OK Linné	1:20
	white forest is too even and gles
3.	apnurmee		Kalevan Rasti	1:21
3.	Serg Doronin		SneGoVik o-team	1:21
3.	KalleBergman		OK Ravinen	1:21
3.	Daynee		Malungs OK	1:21
7.	Bullen		Suraarmaravtegel	1:23
	Comments: There is undervegetation on the semiopen area but not in the white forest, that feels odd. Marshes are not very marshlike, try other vegetation and groundcolour. Forest groundtexture is great. All trees are pretty much the same height, variate them and mix in some birches in variated heights.
7.	RUSIA		monolit	1:23		*****
7.	Daniels		Attunda OK	1:23
7.	Kristo		kristoheinmann@blogspot.com	1:23
7.	Appdreas		Tullinge SK	1:23
7.	OBT		KLS	1:23
13.	sundlof		Gävle OK	1:24
	i think the wide pine tree shouldnt ever be used, its hitbox is not where everyone would like it
13.	Eirik		Nydalens SK	1:24
13.	mansen		GMOK	1:24
13.	Ida Mari		Kristiansand OK	1:24
13.	Ðóñåöêèé Ñåðãåé			1:24		*****
13.	Fredde		nxtg	1:24
13.	rjm		NEOH	1:24		*****
	Green but pleasant forest, good textures
13.	Jakenm		Gävle OK	1:24
13.	Jakob Andersson		Bredaryds SOK	1:24
22.	HPM		NTNUI	1:25
	green a bit dense for my taste..
22.	Matsubitsu		Vehkalahden Veikot	1:25
22.	Michael Granqvist		OK Ravinen	1:25
22.	Êîðñàð		Monolit	1:25
22.	challe_swe		IFK Mora	1:25
22.	Wejan		OLGY Slayers	1:25
22.	MatteA		OK Tisaren	1:25
22.	Kreiberg		OK Roskilde	1:25
22.	Jeremy G		Antwerp Orienteers	1:25
31.	Karl D		OL-Teamet	1:26
31.	Hallmen		OL4	1:26
31.	Tovisen		Knoppen	1:26
31.	tjalvedu		TJALVE	1:26
31.	-=MoGiLaN=-		O'Belarus	1:26		*****
31.	Korik			1:26		*****
31.	Jochen		GMOK	1:26		*****
31.	Halvor Eid Nielsen		NTNUI	1:26
31.	Elxigo		SOL-BoyZ	1:26
	get higher speed in white forest. rest is prima, or maybe ugly trees in lightgreen... (a) lovely dark ground...
40.	Pale		Vehkalahden Veikot	1:27
40.	Ben Sand		viking	1:27
40.	antonsson		Eksjö SOK	1:27
40.	Adriaan Pelckmans		Trol	1:27
44.	PHJ65		SuSe	1:28
44.	A.S.L. Lubina		TV Wattenscheid 01	1:28
44.	Simon Kappel		Haninge SOK	1:28		*****
44.	jeschke		OLG Stroeck	1:28		*****
	Looks good, I like it.
44.	HuggE		SOL-BoyZ	1:28
44.	Robin		FK Göingarna	1:28
44.	Galina Vinogradova		CSKA	1:28
51.	BeN'O		COCS	1:29
	Perhaps too much features in marsh, green is identifable, white good too. ground nice for me. I usually add small tree to avoid far vision. Don't hesitate to make your own tree or remade old one, i use GIMP program, it's free and very usefull. Also you can find good tree at the CF library ! good luck
51.	Knubbe		OK Computer	1:29
51.	TC		Malungs OK Skogsmårdarna	1:29
51.	Moa		SNO	1:29
51.	Heggo		OL4	1:29
56.	thiago		Fuzileiros Navais	1:30
56.	Frzfrz		OK Oachkatzlschwoaf	1:30
56.	Betak		Kalevan Rasti	1:30		*****
56.	kajari			1:30
56.	eickhoff		GMOK	1:30
56.	Skogsjonis		Kexholms SK	1:30
56.	Hjojo		OL4	1:30		*****
63.	Acke Granbarr		OLGY Slayers	1:31
63.	Jakob Schach		OC Schwaben	1:31		*****
63.	engstrom		OK Orion	1:31
66.	janands		Team Pez And Snapple	1:32
66.	Krasimir		Trapezica	1:32
66.	T6nis		Rakvere OK	1:32
66.	stevegregg		BAOC	1:32
66.	furuczd		Farmaceut Bratislava	1:32		*****
66.	Steph Clement-Agoni		TSO	1:32
66.	sparven		IKHP	1:32
66.	Karschtl		USV TU Dresden	1:32
66.	Hollbeck		Bromma-Vällingby SOK	1:32
75.	janof		Farmaceut Bratislava	1:33
75.	jeb		VSO	1:33
75.	yann		EMHM	1:33
75.	anhaktov		Sportident.ru	1:33
75.	Mange		FK Göingarna	1:33
80.	ShvedA		MS Parma	1:34
80.	Björck		OK Älme	1:34		*****
82.	LPasturiza		COSaM	1:35		*****
82.	Jonatan		OK Võru	1:35
82.	Rulle		IFK Göteborg	1:35
85.	Philipp Koch		OC Schwaben	1:36
85.	Anton Karlsson		OK Kullingshof	1:36
87.	pedero		Nord-Østerdal OK	1:37
87.	DNF		Stora Tuna OK	1:37
87.	TimZor		Falköpings AIK OK	1:37		*****
87.	Remitz		Gällstadbygdens sok	1:37
91.	Steken		IF Rigor	1:38
91.	Robin L		FK Göingarna	1:38
93.	Klll		neXus OK	1:39
93.	Vinogradov Mikhail		Alfta-Ösa OK	1:39
95.	tio Pepe		Kalmar	1:40
95.	nessie		OK Ravinen	1:40
95.	Irdan Remark		Post SV Dresden	1:40
98.	honzau		SDO	1:41		*****
	It seems too dense and loads too slow compare to other maps.
98.	Ilirej		Farmaceut Bratislava	1:41
98.	àëåêñàíäð		êîíòóð	1:41
101.	Akva		Odessa	1:42
101.	BekAmk		MTBO SPb Club	1:42
101.	Camel		Farmaceut Bratislava	1:42
104.	Joe Berg		OK Älgen	1:43
105.	Boris Isaikin		DINAMO	1:44		*****
105.	Steffen		OC Schwaben	1:44
107.	andre de veirman		trol	1:45		*****
107.	Jonna Jungåker		Korsnäs IF OK	1:45
109.	Joel		SOK68	1:47		*****
110.	iansmith		CSU	1:48
111.	Robert Tellvik		Tumba Mälarhöjden OK	1:49		*****
111.	Sklenicka		SSU	1:49
113.	BB King		ÖOK	1:50		*****
113.	bigluc		Polisportiva Masi	1:50
115.	lolob		chtiaventure	1:52
115.	ErkS		Kvarnsvedens OK	1:52
115.	lostinthewood		AAA	1:52
118.	Blomerik		OAS	1:54
118.	Mathias Myrefelt		Skarpnäcks OL	1:54
118.	Vexi		Rajamäen Rykmentti	1:54
121.	Champ		Bsk	1:55
122.	Signe Edsen		Nordvest ok	1:58
123.	Elina			2:00
124.	Rainer		OC Schwaben	2:02
125.	Gosha18		VHSO	2:06
126.	Hampus Larsson		FK Göingarna	2:07
127.	Trying			2:09
127.	Helder Marcolino		GD4C	2:09
129.	antfor		L-100 IF	2:10
129.	Storesandgubben		Express	2:10		*****
131.	Linus			2:15
131.	Christian Tingström		OK Klemmingen	2:15
133.	Thor_Norskov		OK_Ost	2:16
134.	Ñåðãåé		ÑÄÞØ	2:17
135.	hanne v		Byåsen IL	2:19		*****
135.	Torgny		Ronneby OK	2:19
137.	Lasse skare Therkildsen		OK-HTF	2:20
138.	Lecramol		OLG KTV Altdorf	2:21
139.	Luka Mihaljevic		Ok Vihor	2:23
139.	Charles_I		OK Linne	2:23
141.	Wetheral		Ebor	2:24
142.	Gustav B		OK Ravinen	2:25
143.	MH		Nydalen SK	2:26
	maybe too slow
144.	LSV		O-club	2:30
145.	Sportgalning		GMOK	2:31
146.	Joni		OC Schwaben	2:34		*****
147.	IM		OK Linné	2:35
148.	Carlos Never Gets Lost		Peña Guara	2:37
149.	Baumann Edouard		OLC SKOG Freiburg	2:41		*****
	okay
150.	Kea		RiOjA-O	2:43		*****
151.	cwgray		UNO	2:45
152.	Segisteg			2:49
152.	nacho rubio		ALCON	2:49		*****
154.	Kalugin Andrey		Moscow	2:50
155.	Thoto		USV TU Dresden	2:58		*****
155.	Wind Runner		FWOC	2:58
157.	Navigatormap		GEBP	3:05
158.	Stephan		OC Schwaben	3:11
159.	Captain Quark		Red Kiwis	3:19
	ok well there are a few things I would change. Just my opinion. Change the trees in the green, that wide pine and that smaller wide pine look tacky. cut down on sticks on the ground. Dont have grass growing in the green areas, have ferns instead. Maybe for the rough open too. Actually just have a low density of ferns all over, and just a tad higher in the green and RO. Also, I would include some of the smaller trees in the marsh area, and scattered throughout, there are no small trees in the forest. I'm sure people will disagree with these but what the hell. The rest is great! Good idea with the preview thing, I might do it for my next Ultima map.
160.	karlvga95		ok kullingshof	3:58
161.	danielpinto		CasteloesPNF	4:08
162.	David G		IKHP	4:25
163.	Vorob'ev Vladimir		Tiras-Orient	4:27
164.	Ura			4:51
165.	denise		wien	6:13		*****
166.	chung chi ming		Akinallance	7:55
167.	roma444		universal	8:17
168.	SiljeH		NTNUI	8:44
169.	bigE		Ottawa OC	10:59		*****
	I liked the way you used grass in the different vegetations.
	gvtoukc		TSN	dnf
	Niklas Olsson		Kopparvägen FC	dnf
	wangis		OLGY Slayers	dnf